Settle it with data

Hydrogen · the two seats · Article · 17 Nov 2026 · 825 words

Why hydrogen has two seats

Hydrogen is element 1, and it sits at the top of group 1 of the periodic table. Yet it is not an alkali metal: it is a nonmetal, with properties like both group 1 and group 17, and some periodic tables give it a box of its own. It is also the most abundant element in the universe.

The Element Guy cover. Two clear glass gas jars stand on a stone bench in evening light. The headline reads Why hydrogen has two seats, with a 1 H tile.

The first entry on the chart is the one that chemists cannot agree where to seat. Here is what the sources say, and why the question stays open.

What hydrogen is

At ordinary temperatures hydrogen is a colourless, odourless, tasteless and nonpoisonous gas [1]. Put it in a sealed glass jar and the jar looks empty. It is made of molecules of H₂, two hydrogen atoms joined together, so chemists call it diatomic [1]. Element 1 is the first entry in the periodic table, in period 1 and group 1 [2][3].

Its standard atomic weight, the average mass of its atoms on the scale chemists use, is 1.0080, give or take 0.0002 [5]. The international commission that sets these values published that figure in its 2024 abridged list [5]. The commission's full list gives hydrogen a range rather than a single number, from 1.00784 to 1.00811, and the abridged figure sits inside that range [5].

One electron

A hydrogen atom has a single electron, and in its ground state, its lowest-energy arrangement, that electron sits in the 1s orbital, the first shell [4]. There is nothing underneath it and nothing beside it.

Pulling that electron away from the atom takes 13.6 electronvolts; NIST's value runs to twelve decimal places, 13.598434599702 eV [4]. An electronvolt (eV) is a very small unit of energy, sized for a single atom. The energy needed to remove an atom's outermost electron is called its first ionisation energy. For hydrogen it is the only ionisation energy there is, since there is only one electron to remove [4]:

H(g) → H⁺(g) + e⁻

The charge balances: a neutral atom on the left, a hydrogen ion with a charge of +1 and an electron with a charge of −1 on the right [4].

Why it has two seats

Hydrogen is a unique nonmetallic element, with properties similar to both the group 1 elements and the group 17 elements [2]. So periodic tables differ on where to put it. Some show it at the top of group 1, some at the top of group 17 as well, and some place it by itself, apart from both groups [2].

The usual seat is group 1, but the textbooks are careful about it. Although hydrogen is in group 1, and also in group 17, it is a nonmetal and not an alkali metal [3]. At ordinary temperatures it is a gas of H₂ molecules, not a solid metal [1][3].

So the two seats are not a mistake on the chart. They record a real overlap: a nonmetal that sits with the alkali metals by position, and shares properties with group 17 as well [2][3]. A box of its own is the plainest way to show both at once [2].

How it reacts

A mixture of hydrogen and oxygen explodes if it is ignited [1]. The product is water, and the reaction is exothermic, meaning it gives out heat [1]:

2H₂(g) + O₂(g) → 2H₂O(l)

There are four hydrogen atoms and two oxygen atoms on each side, so the equation balances [1].

Hydrogen also reacts explosively with fluorine, forming hydrogen fluoride, HF, and under some conditions with chlorine, forming hydrogen chloride, HCl [1]:

H₂(g) + F₂(g) → 2HF(g)
H₂(g) + Cl₂(g) → 2HCl(g)

In each case one molecule of hydrogen and one molecule of the other gas give two molecules of product, with two hydrogen atoms and two of the other atoms on each side [1].

Where hydrogen is found

Astronomers estimate that about 90 per cent of the atoms in the universe are hydrogen atoms, so it is the most abundant element in the universe [1]. That figure is an estimate, and the textbook gives it as one [1]. Put another way, roughly nine atoms in every ten are hydrogen [1].

On Earth, hydrogen's most common compound is a liquid. Water is the most abundant compound of hydrogen found on Earth [1]. Every water molecule, H₂O, holds two hydrogen atoms joined to one oxygen atom, so two of its three atoms are hydrogen [1].

What it is made for

Hydrogen is made on a large scale. Two thirds of the world's hydrogen production goes into making ammonia, according to the textbook; the page does not give the year of that figure [1].

Safety as chemistry

The hazard is the reaction. Hydrogen and oxygen together form a mixture that explodes if ignited, and the reaction that makes water is potentially explosive [1]. Hydrogen's reactions with fluorine, and under some conditions with chlorine, are explosive as well [1]. The gas itself has no colour, no smell and no taste [1].

The short version

  • Element 1, a colourless gas of H₂ molecules [1][2].
  • One electron, in the 1s orbital, removed with 13.6 eV [4].
  • Seated over group 1, sometimes over group 17 too, and sometimes on its own; a nonmetal, not an alkali metal [2][3].
  • About 90 per cent of the atoms in the universe, by astronomers' estimate [1].

— The Element Guy, Punditry. Settle it with data.

Sources

  1. OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, 18.5 “Occurrence, Preparation, and Compounds of Hydrogen”. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/18-5-occurrence-preparation-and-compounds-of-hydrogen (most abundant element, astronomers' estimate of 90% of atoms; colourless, odourless, tasteless, nonpoisonous diatomic gas H₂; water the most abundant compound on Earth; hydrogen and oxygen mixture explodes if ignited, exothermic and potentially explosive; explosive with fluorine forming HF, with chlorine under some conditions forming HCl; two thirds of world production goes to ammonia)
  2. OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, 2.5 “The Periodic Table”. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/2-5-the-periodic-table (unique nonmetal with properties like group 1 and group 17; shown at the top of both groups, or by itself)
  3. OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, 18.1 “Periodicity”. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/18-1-periodicity (in group 1 and also group 17, a nonmetal, not an alkali metal)
  4. NIST Atomic Spectra Database, ionisation energies. https://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/ASD/ie.pl?e_out=0&el_name_out=on&format=0&level_out=on&order=0&shells_out=on&spectra=H-Zn+I&submit=Retrieve+Data&units=1 (ground configuration 1s; first ionisation energy 13.598434599702 eV)
  5. CIAAW, abridged standard atomic weights (2024). https://ciaaw.org/abridged-atomic-weights.htm (hydrogen 1.0080 ± 0.0002; the full list, https://ciaaw.org/atomic-weights.htm, gives the interval [1.00784, 1.00811])